Regulation4 November 2026 · 4 min read

£510 is the number the regulator already knows

The regulator knows what the average broker charges, and the fee-free firms are quoting it back at you. The only answer that holds up is a fair value case you can actually show someone.

What happened

The FCA has done the sums. On its own figures, the average fee customers paid a broker in 2024 was £510. Brokers who charged a fee also picked up an average proc fee of £1,131 on top. Call it £1,641 a case.

Those numbers haven't stayed in a consultation paper. L&C Mortgages, who don't charge clients, said in January that the FCA's work on broker fees "felt like the justification to point more customers towards execution-only".

And fees themselves have hardly shifted. Research since Consumer Duty came in back in July 2023 has the typical fee still sitting at around £500. A few lenders have gone as far as capping what brokers can charge on their products.

Why it matters

Consumer Duty says your fee has to be fair value for what the client actually gets. Not what you'd like to think they get. And if someone asks, you need to be able to show how you reached that view.

This is where a lot of smaller firms are exposed. Plenty wrote a fair value assessment in 2023, filed it, and haven't opened it since. That won't hold up well if a lender, your network or the FCA asks to see it.

The commercial problem is bigger, though. If a client can't tell anyone what your fee bought them, a fee-free broker looks like the same service for nothing. You won't lose that argument on price. You'll lose it because nobody ever made the case to the person paying.

What we'd do this week

Dig out your fair value assessment and check the date on it. Does it describe the firm you run now, including protection and what happens after completion, or the one you ran three years ago?

Then try writing down what the fee is for. Leave hours out of it. The client is paying for judgement, for someone managing the case, and for contact after the keys are handed over. If you struggle to put that on paper, your clients will struggle to see it.

It's also worth asking each adviser to explain the fee in three sentences without apologising for it. You'll learn a lot from who hesitates. And go through every fee you waived or cut in the last six months. Some of those will have been proper decisions. Some will have been nerves.

If you'd like to see how the rest of your firm stacks up, the 12-question quiz is a good start.