Regulation4 November 2026 · 4 min read

The execution-only door is open. Advice has to earn its place.

Since the FCA's Mortgage Rule Review, a lender can talk a customer through their options without it counting as advice. Which leaves every firm with an awkward question. Why would anyone pay for what you do?

What happened

Back in July 2025 the FCA published PS25/11, the first part of its Mortgage Rule Review. It scrapped the old rule that turned almost any back-and-forth conversation about a mortgage into regulated advice, and the change applied straight away.

What replaced it is looser. Firms now have to think about what procedures they need to spot execution-only customers who really ought to have advice or extra support, so they don't come to foreseeable harm. The FCA hung that on Consumer Duty.

The review hasn't stopped there. In July this year the FCA consulted on helping first-time buyers and people who struggle to get a mortgage (CP26/18), and that included where interest-only might fit. AMI broadly welcomed it, but asked the FCA to spell out what "tailored interactive dialogue" means, with real examples, so advisers know where they stand. The FCA's wider plan runs into 2027 and includes AI-assisted advice.

Going the other way, Paradigm has argued that advice should be compulsory for every first-time buyer, and AMI has backed the principle.

Why it matters

On simple cases, a lender's own channel can now do a lot more without calling it advice. You'll notice it first on product transfers and straightforward remortgages.

That doesn't make advice worth less. What it does is make the value much easier for a client to question. If what you offer looks like a rate search followed by an application, an execution-only route is going to look like the same thing, only quicker and free.

Advice still wins where judgement comes in. The self-employed client whose accounts are a mess. The first-time buyer who has no cover in place. The client asking for a longer term when what's really going on is a debt problem.

What we'd do this week

Have a look at last year's cases and work out how many were simple transfers or like-for-like remortgages. That slice of your income is the part most at risk from execution-only.

For those simple cases, be honest about what your advice adds. If the answer is "not much", you've got two choices. Change the service, or change what you charge for it.

The flip side is to go after the clients who genuinely need an adviser: first-time buyers, the self-employed, later-life borrowers, anyone with gaps in their protection. That's where this market is pushing advisers anyway. Keep an eye out for the final rules from CP26/18 as well, because they'll shape the first-time buyer market next year.

If you want to see where your firm is strong and where it's thin, take the 12-question quiz.